After losing a loved one to someone else’s negligence, families in Orlando face one of the most painful questions imaginable: What are their chances of winning a wrongful death suit? At Burnetti, P.A., we understand the weight of that question. It is not just about legal strategy. It is about justice, accountability, and securing the financial support your family needs to move forward. Grief is already an overwhelming burden. Navigating the legal system on top of it should not have to fall entirely on your shoulders. If you are searching for an Orlando wrongful death lawyer who will fight for you, this guide explains what shapes your odds, what Florida law requires, and how to build the strongest possible case from the start.
The likelihood of success in a wrongful death claim depends on how clearly negligence and damages can be established. Estimates place the trial success rate for these cases at roughly 60%, which is notably higher than the overall success rate for personal injury cases. Solid evidence, such as police reports and expert testimony, plays a central role in connecting the death directly to the defendant’s actions.
Understanding your odds starts with a look at how these cases perform nationally. Wrongful death claims tend to succeed at trial more often than general personal injury claims, with estimates placing the trial success rate at approximately 60%. That figure reflects cases that go all the way to a verdict, but it does not represent the full picture.
A significant portion of wrongful death cases are resolved before trial, through negotiated settlements that still deliver meaningful compensation to surviving families. The overall rate of favorable outcomes, counting both trial victories and settlements, is considerably higher than 60%. That context matters when families are weighing whether to pursue a claim.
The strength of a wrongful death case hinges on the ability to prove negligence, meaning the defendant owed a duty of care, breached that duty, and that breach directly caused the death. Cases with clear liability and documented losses tend to perform better, both at trial and in settlement negotiations. The more thoroughly a case is built from the beginning, the stronger the position families hold throughout the entire legal process. Families who engage experienced legal counsel early benefit from strategic guidance before critical decisions are made.
Florida wrongful death cases follow state-specific rules that affect both who can file and what compensation is available. Florida’s Wrongful Death Act governs these claims and limits eligible parties to the personal representative of the estate, who files on behalf of surviving family members, such as spouses, children, and parents. Understanding these eligibility requirements early is essential, since filing errors can delay or jeopardize a case before it even begins.
Florida also applies a comparative fault standard, which means a court may reduce damages if the deceased is found to share any percentage of fault for the incident. That makes thorough investigation and evidence gathering especially important in Florida cases, since the defense will often look for ways to assign partial blame. Countering those arguments requires a proactive legal strategy supported by solid documentation, including scene photographs, independent witness accounts, and medical records that establish the full sequence of events leading to the death. The stronger that foundation, the harder it becomes for the defense to shift responsibility.
Expert witnesses carry significant weight in Florida wrongful death litigation. Under Florida Statute §90.702, expert testimony must meet specific standards to be admissible. Cases that include well-qualified experts who can speak to causation and damages tend to fare better in Florida courts, both during settlement discussions and at trial.
The vast majority of wrongful death cases, across all practice areas and jurisdictions, resolve through settlement rather than a jury trial. Estimates suggest that more than 90% of civil cases settle before reaching a verdict. Wrongful death cases follow that same pattern, and for good reason.
Settlement offers families a faster resolution and a guaranteed outcome, avoiding the risk and emotional toll of a trial. Insurance companies and defendants often prefer settlement as well, because trial outcomes are unpredictable and legal costs escalate quickly the longer a case runs. For families already dealing with loss, avoiding years of litigation can also provide a measure of emotional closure that a drawn-out courtroom battle rarely offers.
That does not mean families should accept the first offer they receive. Early settlement offers are often undervalued, particularly when long-term financial losses and full medical costs have not yet been calculated. An experienced attorney will evaluate every offer against the case’s realistic trial value and advise accordingly. It is also worth noting that a willingness to go to trial, backed by thorough preparation, often motivates defendants to offer more reasonable terms during negotiation. Going to trial remains the right choice when the defense refuses to offer fair compensation.
Several factors consistently distinguish strong wrongful death claims from weaker ones. Families should understand each of these when evaluating their own situation, because the presence or absence of even one factor can meaningfully shift a case’s trajectory.
Each of these factors weighs on the outcome. Cases that check multiple boxes consistently perform better, whether in settlement negotiations or at trial. When several of these elements align, the overall value of the claim increases significantly, both in court and at the negotiating table.
CALL BURNETTI. WE’RE READY.
Not all wrongful death claims carry equal odds of success. Certain case types tend to produce stronger outcomes due to the availability of evidence and the relative ease of establishing liability.
Motor vehicle accidents are among the most frequently litigated wrongful death cases. When a driver is cited by law enforcement, tested for impairment, or captured on a traffic camera, the evidentiary foundation is often strong from the start. Trucking cases in which federal safety regulations apply can also be highly favorable when records show violations. These cases often involve detailed logbooks, inspection reports, and company policies that can be used to demonstrate a pattern of negligence.
Workplace fatalities involving safety code violations and premises liability cases where a property owner ignored known hazards also tend to succeed when documentation is thorough. Product liability cases, where a defective item caused the death, benefit from technical expert analysis that can be compelling to a jury. In all of these scenarios, having an attorney who understands how to gather and present that evidence is essential.
Cases involving clear wrongdoing and a defendant with adequate insurance coverage or assets to satisfy a judgment have the best overall prospects. The chances of winning a wrongful death suit improve significantly when liability is straightforward and losses are well documented.
Even cases that appear strong at the outset can face serious obstacles. Understanding the common reasons wrongful death claims fall short helps families and their attorneys avoid the same pitfalls.
Insufficient evidence is the leading cause of failure. When the cause of death cannot be clearly linked to the defendant’s actions, or when key records are missing or inconsistent, the case becomes vulnerable. Shared fault is another challenge in Florida, where comparative negligence rules can reduce or eliminate a recovery if the deceased is found partly responsible. In some cases, defendants aggressively pursue this angle to minimize their financial exposure.
Missing the statute-of-limitations deadline is also a critical error. In Florida, families generally have two years from the date of death to file a wrongful death claim, with limited exceptions. Cases filed late are typically dismissed outright, regardless of merit. Poor legal representation and inadequate case preparation round out the most common reasons wrongful death lawsuits do not succeed. Choosing an attorney with specific experience in Florida wrongful death law is one of the most important decisions a family can make.
There are concrete steps families can take to improve their chances of a successful outcome. Taking action early and staying organized throughout the process makes a measurable difference in how a case develops.
Each of these steps directly improves the likelihood of a favorable resolution, whether through settlement or a verdict at trial. Families who approach the process deliberately, with experienced legal support, are far better positioned than those who wait.
Client Reviews
Compassionate, friendly and professional law firm. I was hurt in a car accident and didn’t know where to turn. They dealt with the insurance company on my behalf and that was a tremendous relief. I could concentrate on healing. I am so grateful for their support and help. I definitely am in the best hands. The best law firm if you want a caring knowledgeable attorney on your side. Thank you, Burnetti, PA.
View More Reviews on Google Maps.
Legal representation is one of the most significant variables in how a wrongful death case turns out. Families who attempt to navigate these claims without an attorney face substantial disadvantages against insurance companies and defense counsel with extensive resources and experience. Insurance carriers have teams of adjusters and lawyers whose primary goal is to limit payouts, and they are skilled at doing exactly that.
An experienced wrongful death attorney manages every aspect of the case, from gathering evidence and retaining experts to negotiating with insurers and preparing for trial. Our attorneys at Burnetti, P.A. understand Florida wrongful death law and have the trial experience to pursue every available option on behalf of families who have suffered an unimaginable loss. We handle the legal complexity so families can focus on what matters most during an extraordinarily difficult time.
The question of the chances of winning a wrongful death suit does not have a single answer. Every case is shaped by its own facts, evidence, and circumstances. But with the right attorney, thorough preparation, and a clear evidentiary record, families in Orlando give themselves the best possible foundation for justice.
If your family has lost a loved one due to someone else’s negligence, do not wait to seek legal guidance. Burnetti, P.A., represents Orlando families in wrongful death cases and is ready to evaluate your claim.
Call us today at (800) 287-6388 and speak with an attorney who will fight to recover the justice your family deserves.
Board-Certified Civil Trial Lawyer and founder of Burnetti, P.A., Doug Burnetti has spent his career fighting for the injured across Florida. Known for his courtroom skill and dedication to justice, he leads a firm built on integrity, strength, and results—recognized by Florida Super Lawyers and Martindale-Hubbell® for excellence in trial advocacy. He is also the recipient of the Jerry A. DeVane Award, presented by the Lakeland Bar Association.
This page has been written, edited, and reviewed by a team of legal writers following our comprehensive editorial guidelines. This page was approved by attorney Doug Burnetti, who has more than 31 years of fighting for injured clients across Florida.
If you or a loved one has been seriously injured, please fill out the form below for your free consultation or call us at 1-800-287-6388.
call us at 1-800-287-6388
Message Us 
Call Us